Experiencing OCTOPATH TRAVELER 0: Not suggesting it's "Bad", but it's not good.
The best way to describe this game: if you took Triangle Strategy, made it a regular turn-based game and added a half-assed town builder, you'd basically end up with this game. Which is fine...just don't call it "Octopath" is all.
What I Liked
β Music is always a treat.
β The "mini-stories" are actually good.
β Quality English voice acting.
What I Didn't Like
π It suffers from what feels like disjointed storytelling. It really isn't an "Octopath" game, frankly. You're not playing out the eight paths. They could (and should) have just had this be a new IP and it'd been a perfectly serviceable game.
π Grinding is basically mandatory - which is unfortunate, since once the random encounters were removed, the game became a lot more tolerable.
π The story you're presented at first is disconnected from the "real" story. You choose a scenario that is basically just to determine which of the action traits is easier to master; but the people involved in those mini-stories basically have little to do with the "real" story. Those mini-stories are actually quite a bit more interesting, because the larger "real" story is thrown at you (despite plenty of cutscenes) in a way that you simply don't care about what happens to most of these people.
π At two points, you'll encounter what up to then is your strongest team member, only to have them just randomly leave. The game doesn't play favorites, but you'll find certain characters are almost indispensable (Celsus) and certain ones are garbage (Saoirse). As with real Octopath games, the characters don't interact with each other beyond the initial meeting.
π The game does seem to suffer from "girlboss" - characters like Sita become stronger than it seems they should, and others such as Phenn get left in the dust. Most of the men end up with lower SP for no obvious reason - Pius is the only notable exception to this that we saw.
π Has "they/them" pronouns for your main character, and "Physique" instead of gender. So just be aware there's a bit of wokeness running around outside of the girlboss stuff.
Summary
It's not "bad". It's just not Octopath anything, and should have been a different IP entirely. It's a pale shadow of the real Octopath games.